Learn trading ideas & strategies from TradeKing's experts

Upcoming Live Events
More live events...
Learn it. Trade it.

Open your TradeKing account today!

Upcoming Live Events
More live events...

Comparing ETFs and Index Mutual Funds


Exchange-traded funds and index mutual funds are very similar investments in some ways. Both can provide a source of diversification for your portfolio and a means to follow a particular sector or index. However, this is where the similarities end. As noted below, there are several differences that can make one of these investments a better choice for your portfolio. Please take some time to let these differences soak in. After all, these variations may make the distinction between reaching your investment goals and falling short of the mark.

Before investing in any mutual fund or exchange-traded fund, carefully consider information contained in the prospectus, including investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Free prospectuses may be ordered from the fund company or send a request to service@tradeking.com. Many but not all prospectuses are available online. Not all mutual funds are available through TradeKing. Read the prospectus carefully before investing. Investment returns will fluctuate and are subject to market volatility so that an investor's shares, when redeemed or sold, may be worth more or less than their original cost. Unlike mutual funds, shares of ETFs are not individually redeemable directly with the fund company. Some specialized exchange-traded funds can be subject to additional market risks.



Feature

ETFs

Index Mutual Funds

Intra-day trading

Yes

No, orders placed during the day are executed at the close of trading

Diversification across a number of securities

Yes

Yes

Tracks index or sector

Yes

Yes

Buy on margin

Yes

No

Sell short

Yes

No

Expenses

Brokerage fees are incurred with each transaction, and there is a spread between bid and ask prices

May have any or all of the following:

  • management fees
  • 12b-1 fees
  • redemption fees
  • sales loads

Tax considerations

ETFs typically make fewer capital gains distributions

Must distribute any capital gains and dividends annually to investors, which may create a taxable event

Redemptions

Must be sold through a broker

Shares may be redeemed directly with fund company






Related Strategies

333 Back Spread w/Calls Image
Back Spread with Calls This is an interesting and unusual strategy. Essentially, you’re selling an at-the-money short call spread in order to help pay for the extra out-of-the-money long call...

1362 Short Index ETF
Short Index ETF An index exchange-traded fund is typically comprised of most or all of the stocks that make up a particular index, such as the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the S...

522 Long Common Stock on Margin
Long Common Stock on Margin This strategy is similar to long common stock, but on steroids. That’s because when buying stock on margin you normally put up only half of the money to purchase the...

More strategies...

All-Star Analysis

Dispatches From the Market Trenches - Part 2 on 02/05/2014
Welcome back to our two-part series of “lessons learned” and other nuggets of wisdom from TradeKing investors. To recap: first thing in...

Tuesday Midday Market Call on 01/24/2014
Get solid market analysis and potential trading ideas. Take 15 minutes of your lunch with Barron’s columnist and Chartered Market...

Option Basics Course on 06/28/2016
div.content_level3.video embed { width: 650px !important; height: 650px !important; margin: auto !important; } span.left, span...

More analysis...

On-Demand Videos

Adjusting Iron Condors, part 2

Sit in with Mark Wolfinger as he gets into the specifics of this ever-popular strategy. The focus of part 2 covers...


Finding Potential Opportunities Using Weekly Options

Many option traders are used to only trading options that expire every month. The introduction of weekly expiring...


Finding Your Target Price

Every investor should have a target price in mind when making an investment. Without one, how would you gauge if...


More videos...